Well that’s it, the counting has ended and my first experience as an election candidate is over. It’s been fun, bruising, expensive, invigorating, educational and one of the most interesting experiences of my life. Maybe it will be repeated, maybe it won’t, I genuinely don’t know. But if it is it will need to be different.
It was a big ask. I was a novice candidate in the Europeans, 22 opponents (a record number for the constituency), big hitters in terms of candidates and parties. The timing was all wrong for reasons you can Google the Irish Times about and the campaign was even interrupted, and yes foreseeably too, for a precious 3 days.
I knew from the outset that I would need to get into the mainstream debate and the extent to which I succeeded or failed in this would determine relative success or failure. I never got into the debate. In the entire campaign I got 2 minutes on RTE TV, 0 minutes on RTE Radio, a 30 minute debate with Ciaran Cuffe and Sinead Gibney on Newstalk, a slot on Phoenix FM, an EchoChamber podcast and a most enjoyable podcast with Mario Rosenstock the day before the vote. That was my broadcast media exposure. Kenneth Fox did a long interview with me for BreakingNews.ie but other long interviews I gave for articles in the Independent and Examiner were blocked by Editorial, or whoever.
I’m convinced RTE breached their own guidelines in relation to choosing the 8 candidates for the Primetime Dublin debate. Uniquely in Dublin they had no Independent on the panel. But RTE don’t surprise me. New ‘management’ or not they still haven’t forgiven me for having the temerity to successfully clear my name after they defamed me over Apollo House. In Donnybrook old grudges die hard it seems.
I wasn’t surprised by the paucity of coverage. Disappointed maybe given the manner in which I co-operated with media and never hid away from them (even during some very difficult time and issues) over 25 years. But not surprised. So, given that nothing was perfect and I knew it was a massive risk why did I do it?
Well firstly I’m passionate about trying to make a difference and since I beat cancer I haven’t had that opportunity. I’ve been living a half-life, hidden away and crushed. My lead Oncologist Professor James Paul O’Neill told me that ‘you didn’t beat cancer to live half a life’ but half a life I’ve been living. Here’s a personal story. You ready?
I’m normally a sociable sort. Confident. Like people and like meeting people. But not anymore. Mandy and I alternate walking Frida in the morning. On Mandy’s days she takes her off to meet other dogs and their owners in our community. On my days I take her away off where I think there’ll be no people. My confidence got destroyed. It was crushed. Betrayal and abandonment do that and are meant to do that. And it works. I could feel myself shrinking and stooping and maybe at times even cowering.
That’s not me. That’s not Bobby Ogle’s son. That’s not the person Mandy married 7 short years ago. So I wanted to feel alive again doing something I was passionate about, my values, my beliefs, testing myself, getting ‘back out there’.
Did it work? Well yes. I’ve never felt more alive, I loved meeting people again, I had great fun with people who agree with me and also people who don’t. I told people NOT to vote for me. I told them in that published EchoChamber Podcast and I also told a very nice woman who believes climate change and Covid are hoax’s that she shouldn’t vote for me. I’m not sure such ‘tactics’ are in any candidate manual but I was determined that if I was to run only once that at least my campaign would be true to my values. There’s enough flip flopping and pandering to every angry tweet going on from others already – not least the Government parties!
We had a night of real challenge but one that was also conducted respectfully with 4 other Independent candidates in DCU and I had long chats afterwards with Malachy Steenson, Gavin Pepper and their followers. Damn it whatever our differences we have to face each other like human beings and talk, discuss them and argue them out. And we did. Vincent Browne chaired the formalities as expertly as he has ever done anything.
Some stats for those interested and who might be considering doing it themselves. It cost me €11,000 of my own (borrowed) money of which I got just under €3000 back through donations. I had a solid team of about 20 people, more in theory but the really active ones numbered about 20. I had an Election Agent who is a star and was drafted in 24 hours before registration after my actual Election Agent and Campaign Manager quit on me at the last minute when she realised the size of the task. She tried to get me to quit too. Not a chance and I’m glad I didn’t. I’d still be ‘hiding’ if I had. I’m done with that carry on but more of that later. I produced 45000 leaflets and An Post delivered the normal 465,000 flyers which they censored removing my views on Israel’s genocide in Gaza. I’ve made a formal complaint about that which is currently under investigation. I haven’t fully decided whether to complain about RTE or not. Oh, and I put up 150 posters. To put that in context Aodhan O’Riordain had 5000 up and Barry Andrews had 10,000 up. I think Sinn Fein had even more. But you see I had to pay for mine. So 150 it was.
It’s not an even playing field as what I have set out demonstrates and it could be made more so. A rational thing would be to ban posters but they give those with the money and power such an advantage that they’ll never allow that. Another idea would be to run a public information ad showing people how to vote. It was quite staggering seeing the mistakes people made on ballot papers rendering their votes invalid and its clear the phenomenon was as bad across all 3 constituencies. Also the order of the names should be randomised on the ballot paper, not simply listed in alphabetical order. A computer should do this before the election. It was amazing to see voting papers that were simply marked 1,2,3 from the first name down. In constituencies were ballot papers can be two feet long it’s ridiculous.
None of these measures would have benefitted me in any material way or would make my vote any greater but I do think it is valid to record my observations and I do so simply for that reason. Overall the 4 most popular candidates won by a comfortable measure and the system, for all its imperfections and its staggering slowness, worked and produced the result that voters wanted. What struck me, and has done for some time now, was the bullying of me by the left. I already knew I was somehow the one worker the left deemed not deserving of workplace solidarity and it was actually said to me before the election by a friend and confidante. I was also told not to run. That I was ‘splitting the left vote’. I’m not sure what that is myself. Is it voting with AfD and Hungarian MEP’s on protecting imperialist Russia? Or is it voting for a party that have always opposed left unity on any terms but their own? I see others accusing PBP (who I don’t vote for and have very little reason to like) of somehow not being entitled to run either. This is the same PBP who run in every election, who are a proper party with proper rules and an actual conference and a proper website and who allow for open membership and make themselves actually publicly accountable as a party, and who – whatever I or anyone else thinks of them – have an absolute right to run in every election. They even offered others (not me, see below) a voting pact but it got thrown back in their faces. To argue that they had no right to run a candidate is out and out bullying but that’s what the claimed left do most in Ireland to those that question from within. I can’t speak for elsewhere but it is definitely the case here.
As to me? I’m told that I’m ‘cancelled’. A few veiled threats have come my way too. C’est la vie. I didn’t need this election to teach me what I was dealing with, what ‘the left’ are capable of, the bile, the toxicity, the faux claims of ‘solidarity’ and the equally faux concern for ‘workers rights’.
I hope our 4 just elected MEP’s put actual workers’ rights at the top of their agenda. I hope they bring the lessons of genuine public housing in Europe back to Dublin. I hope, and I know in Lynn Boylan’s case and perhaps others too, that the people of Palestine will continue to have Irish friends in the European Parliament calling out Israeli genocide and the continuing Nakba. And I hope over the next 5 years they, individually and collectively, that they actually do something for Dublin this time. Or at least turn up here. Maybe open genuine constituency offices and hold genuine public meetings bringing examples of some better practices in Europe on healthcare, childcare and drug treatment to Dublin so that voters can learn to demand these things here too.
As to me? We’ll see how the ‘cancelling’ goes. Life’s a journey and every day is a school day. This has been a great, great experience. Real, sobering, life affirming. I’m taking Frida off now to meet the other dogs and their owners in our community. Onwards!’
magnificent publish, very informative. I ponder why the other experts
of thjs sector do noot realize this. Youu should proceed your
writing. I’m sure, you’ve a great readers’ basxe already! https://odessaforum.Biz.ua/
Ah Brendan. Great Blog. I had lost my own confidence recently and I think I am finding my feet after a medical issue. I wish you had been Elected. You would have been great for Ireland and Dublin of course. Maybe the General Election ?
I voted Labour, I also follow Leeds United so you can probably already see a small pattern there … I gave you a third preference, should have given you higher. You’re a rock of sense , thanks a mil for running, please do it again, ta
I’m not in your constituency Brendan but if was, I would have given you a vote though I wouldn’t always agree with you. I loved listening to you on radio and I always felt you were real and you fought for the people you represented. I myself have long given up on the so called left in this country. They dictate to us on how we should think and what we should believe. They are mostly out of touch and elitist.
I’m really glad you are back and I hope I’ll hear that great voice talking sense again soon.
Stay strong
Commiserations on not making it this time
The Establishment of FfFg green etc claim.to be the centre
A.lie , the left while well meaning are to hung up on being always right excuse the pun.
I think maybe I’m.wrong that you may be the true centre and hopefully can muster the centr as a political force
Brendan! I think you’re an inspirational character ever since the days of the Louth Locomotive Drivers Association (have I the name right there?) and how you were never intimidated or fazed in interviews and held the line in the face of powerful opposition. I’m having my own ‘Industrial’ struggles at the moment and I’m greatly buoyed by thoughts of your courage and determination in the face of overwhelming odds even though I hardly know much about you other than like myself you’re a solid Dundalk man. If I’d been able to give you my No.1 I would have. Keep the faith and march bravely on through the slings and arrows, no noble deed is ever wasted! NO PASARAN! Shane
A real pleasure to be Brendan Ogle’s Election Agent.
A man of integrity.